The Impact of the Deflationary Cycle (2020-2022) in Switzerland: An Analysis for Investors and Real Estate Investors

In recent years, Switzerland has encountered a peculiar situation known as negative inflation, or deflation. This phenomenon indicates a decrease in the general price level of goods and services, which surprisingly means consumers are paying less than before.

A stunning aerial view of traditional Swiss mountain ranges

Understanding Negative Inflation

Negative inflation can be puzzling, especially since most economies typically view moderate inflation as a sign of health. When prices consistently decline, consumers might delay purchases in expectation of even lower prices, consequently causing reduced demand. In Switzerland, several factors contribute to this deflation, including a robust Swiss Franc, a stable economy, and cautious consumer spending.

Chart illustrating significant negative inflationary pressure with fluctuating trends.

Monetary Policy and Switzerland's Deflationary Cycle (2020-2022)

The Swiss National Bank (SNB) played a crucial role in shaping the economic landscape during Switzerland's deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022. The SNB's monetary policy was characterized by several key strategies and challenges:

1. Interest Rate Policy: The SNB maintained a zero interest rate policy to stimulate economic activity and combat deflationary pressures. However, this policy was not enough to counteract the deflationary trends entirely. 1
   

2. Currency Interventions: The SNB engaged in significant foreign currency interventions to prevent the Swiss franc from appreciating further. A stronger Swiss franc would have made Swiss exports less competitive and further weakened the economy. Analysts suggested that the SNB would likely continue these interventions to prevent the country from slipping into a deflationary environment 6.
   

3. Inflation Targeting: The SNB aimed to keep inflation within a target range of 0-2%. However, the yearly inflation rate measured by the consumer price index was negative six times between 2010 and 2020, indicating deflationary pressures. The SNB's efforts to maintain a "fair" exchange rate of 1.20 francs per euro were unsuccessful, as the Swiss franc appreciated against the euro, breaking parity in 2022 7.
   

4. Monetary Base Expansion: The SNB engaged in a prolonged phase of easy monetary policy, significantly expanding the monetary base. This policy was intended to weaken the Swiss franc and stimulate economic activity. However, it also led to inflated real estate prices and eroded purchasing power, clouding Switzerland's economic future 7.
   

5. Policy Adjustments: In response to inflationary pressures, the SNB tightened monetary policy by raising the policy rate and allowing the exchange rate to appreciate. This strategy aimed to fulfill the SNB's price stability mandate. However, the SNB also experienced financial losses due to higher interest payments to banks and other factors 8.
   

6. Global Factors: The post-pandemic era brought about a sharp increase in consumer demand and disruptions in supply chains, compounded by an escalation of energy costs due to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. These factors collectively fueled a spike in headline inflation across the world, including Switzerland 8.

The SNB's monetary policy during the deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022 was characterized by a combination of interest rate management, currency interventions, and inflation targeting. While these measures aimed to stabilize the economy and combat deflation, they also faced significant challenges, including the appreciation of the Swiss franc and the erosion of purchasing power. The SNB's policy adjustments and interventions were crucial in navigating the complex economic landscape during this period.

Impact on Key Sectors

Navigating the complexities of investment in a deflationary economy, where the value and risk of capital can fluctuate unpredictably.

Employment Rates

The deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022 had a significant impact on employment rates in Switzerland. The economic slowdown led to a decrease in employment rates as businesses struggled to maintain profitability in a low-price environment. The unemployment rate reached a 20-year low of 1.9% in February 2023, indicating a tight labor market. However, the deflationary pressures and economic uncertainties posed challenges for sustained employment growth 11.

Consumer Spending Trends

Consumer spending trends were influenced by various factors during the deflationary cycle. Private consumption remained robust despite the deflationary pressures, as households continued to spend on goods and services. The consumer price inflation rate was below the target of 2% since June 2023 and fell almost continuously until Spring 2024, indicating that consumers benefited from lower prices. However, the overall economic uncertainty and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on certain industries affected consumer confidence and spending patterns 12.

Export Volumes

Swiss exports faced significant challenges during the deflationary cycle. The strength of the Swiss franc made Swiss exports less competitive, leading to a decline in export volumes. The country's growth outlook was weakened as a result. However, Switzerland's GDP experienced marked growth in the second quarter of 2024, primarily driven by the chemical and pharmaceutical industry and robust goods exports. The industrial sector performed weakly, as did domestic demand, highlighting the mixed impact of the deflationary cycle on exports 13.

International Trade Relations

Switzerland's international trade relations were also affected by the deflationary cycle. Political relations between Switzerland and the European Union remained uncertain, with negotiations over an all-embracing trade agreement collapsing in May 2021. This uncertainty, along with the appreciation of the Swiss franc, posed challenges for Swiss exporters. Trade relationships between Switzerland and the EU crumbled as existing trade agreements had not been updated in years, further complicating the trade environment 12.

The deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022 had a profound impact on key sectors of the Swiss economy. Employment rates were affected by economic uncertainties, consumer spending trends were influenced by deflationary pressures and the COVID-19 pandemic, export volumes were challenged by the strength of the Swiss franc, and international trade relations were strained by political uncertainties and currency appreciation. These factors collectively shaped the economic landscape during this period and highlighted the complex interplay between monetary policy, economic performance, and global trade dynamics.

Impact on Property Investment and Property Ownership

The deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022 had significant implications for property investment and property ownership in Switzerland. The low-interest-rate environment and deflationary pressures influenced real estate prices, investment behaviors, and ownership trends.

Property investments were impacted.

Property Investment

1. Interest Rates and Real Estate Prices: The deflationary cycle was characterized by low and even negative interest rates, which significantly impacted real estate prices. Investors sought higher yields in the real estate market due to the low returns on other investments. This demand drove up property prices, making Switzerland one of Europe's most expensive real estate markets. House prices increased more than 80% in the last 15 years, and prices were around seven times average Swiss incomes, the highest level in over 40 years 16.
   

2. Investment Trends: The low-interest-rate environment attracted yield-hungry investors to the real estate market. However, despite the high prices, many classic indicators of a bubble, such as excess supply and speculative buyers, were absent. The Swiss real estate market, including houses, apartments, and investment properties, experienced a stellar run with sharp price increases. This trend was driven by both domestic and international investors seeking stable and high-yielding assets 16.
   

3. Real Estate Market Vulnerabilities: The real estate market in Switzerland faced potential vulnerabilities due to the high levels of investment and exposure. Banks had significant real estate exposures, with a mortgage-to-GDP ratio of 148% in 2022. Of these mortgages, 62.3% were for owner-occupied residential properties, 23.0% for investment-purpose residential properties, and 14.7% for commercial real estate (CRE). Real estate properties constituted 9% of total assets managed by Swiss insurance companies, with mortgages accounting for another 7%, highlighting the significant exposure of the financial sector to the real estate market 17.

Property Ownership

1. Homeownership Trends: The deflationary environment and low-interest rates made property ownership more accessible for some, as mortgage rates were favorable. However, the high property prices relative to incomes posed challenges for first-time buyers and those with lower incomes. The price-to-income ratio reached its highest level in over 40 years, making it difficult for many to enter the property market 16.

2. Mortgage Market Dynamics: The mortgage market in Switzerland was characterized by a high proportion of fixed-rate mortgages, which provided stability for homeowners. However, the low-interest-rate environment also led to increased borrowing, which could pose risks if interest rates were to rise significantly. The arrears rate related to housing increased from 5.0% in 2012 to 7.1% in 2022, signaling growing financial strain due to housing expenses 17.

3. Property Ownership Distribution: The distribution of property ownership in Switzerland was influenced by the deflationary cycle. Investment-purpose real estate (IPRE) became a significant part of the market, with a growing number of properties owned by investors rather than owner-occupiers. This trend was driven by the search for yield in a low-interest-rate environment and the stability of the Swiss real estate market 17.

The deflationary cycle from 2020 to 2022 had a profound impact on property investment and property ownership in Switzerland. Low-interest rates and deflationary pressures drove up real estate prices, attracting investors and posing challenges for first-time buyers. The real estate market faced potential vulnerabilities due to high levels of investment and exposure, while property ownership trends were influenced by the favorable mortgage rates and the search for yield. These factors collectively shaped the real estate landscape during this period and highlighted the complex interplay between monetary policy, investment behaviors, and property market dynamics.

Key Takeaways

The deflationary cycle in Switzerland from 2020 to 2022 was driven by a combination of monetary policy, global economic factors, and domestic challenges. The Swiss National Bank's (SNB) zero interest rate policy and currency interventions aimed to combat deflationary pressures but faced significant challenges due to the strength of the Swiss franc and the erosion of purchasing power. The deflationary environment had a profound impact on key sectors of the Swiss economy, including employment, consumer spending, exports, and international trade relations.

Employment rates were affected by economic uncertainties, while consumer spending remained robust despite deflationary pressures. Export volumes were challenged by the strong Swiss franc, making Swiss exports less competitive. International trade relations were strained by political uncertainties and the appreciation of the Swiss franc. Property investment and ownership were significantly influenced by the low-interest-rate environment, driving up real estate prices and attracting investors. However, this also posed challenges for first-time buyers and increased the vulnerabilities in the real estate market.

Overall, the deflationary cycle highlighted the complex interplay between monetary policy, economic performance, and global trade dynamics. The SNB's policy adjustments and interventions were crucial in navigating the economic landscape during this period, but the challenges posed by the strong Swiss franc and the deflationary pressures required ongoing vigilance and adaptability.

References

• 1 Switzerland | Economic Indicators | Moody's Analytics

• 2 Switzerland and the IMF

• 3 Switzerland’s economy suffers from low inflation?

• 4 Switzerland: Selected Issues in: IMF Staff Country Reports Volume 2024 Issue 180 (2024)

• 5 How Switzerland beat high inflation; Why the Swiss economy is strong

• 6 Switzerland is now flirting with deflation, causing a dilemma for its central bank

• 7 Switzerland’s economy suffers from low inflation?

• 8 Switzerland: Selected Issues in: IMF Staff Country Reports Volume 2024 Issue 180 (2024)

• 9 The SNB’s monetary policy strategy | Swiss National Bank

• 10 ‘Pulse of Switzerland’: inflation making life difficult for people in Switzerland – two-thirds feeling the pressure | Deloitte Switzerland

• 11 Switzerland and the IMF

• 12 Switzerland: Country File, Economic Risk Analysis | Coface

• 13 Economic forecast: Below-average growth, inflation lower than previously expected

• 14 Switzerland - Market Overview

• 15 Switzerland: Selected Issues in: IMF Staff Country Reports Volume 2024 Issue 180 (2024)

• 16 Swiss housing market outlook, forecasts 2022 | Lombard Odier

• 17 Real Estate Markets and Vulnerabilities: The Case of Switzerland in: IMF Staff Country Reports Volume 2024 Issue 180 (2024)

• 18 Interest rates and real estate prices: a panel study | Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics | Full Text